Picture
Picture
Name and Title
Christopher Gaytan
Partner
Associate
Year of Call

2017 (Ontario)
2006 (Mexico)

Memberships
Publications
Description

Christopher Gaytan

Complex economic crimes carried out by insiders are a growing concern for many global businesses — but when fraud has been identified, it is crucial for counsel to act quickly and connect with their counterparts in other jurisdictions, says Toronto commercial litigator Christopher Gaytan.

According to PwC’s 2018 Global Economic Crime and Fraud Survey, 49 per cent of global organizations indicate they have experienced economic crime in the past two years — with just over half of all frauds perpetrated by people working inside the organization.

Gaytan, an associate with Shibley Righton LLP’s Toronto office, says in corporate fraud cases, there are generally three elements, or a ‘fraud triangle’ in place that can explain the reasoning behind the fraud — pressure, opportunity and rationalization.

“Pressure is usually the financial aspect — a person wants to obtain a financial benefit or maintain a lifestyle that they previously had,” he tells AdvocateDaily.com.

“Opportunity is usually when they are in a position where they can take advantage, such as an insider,” Gaytan says. “If you have the information, you know how the business works, putting you in a privileged position where you have the access and ability to act in secret.

“The third element is the rationalization that most fraudsters don’t see themselves as criminals. They usually believe they are victims of circumstances, or they say, for example, ‘I just did what I was asked to do,’ or they tend to minimize the harm done by the crime,” he adds.

Ultimately, Gaytan says many organizations may not be aware that they have fallen victim to fraud until they implement a significant change to their corporate structure or they go through an audit.

An example of this trend — and of the complexity of fraud cases in general — was recently seen in a global case that spanned a number of jurisdictions, including Ontario, involving a South American pension fund, in which Gaytan recently acted as co-counsel for the plaintiff.

In this case, he says, a number of fraudulent investments in Ontario were in place for years, and a few members of the then board of directors were aware of the fraudulent scheme. These insiders were working together with outsiders to perpetrate the fraud. It wasn’t until the full board underwent a complete changeover and contemplated an audit that the significant problem was discovered and external legal counsel was retained.

“The court, in this case, found that the fraud was committed with the knowledge of the insiders — members of the board of directors. These insiders helped parties to channel investments and divest funds to offshore accounts. Of course, most of these investments were misleading and fraudulent, and they were facilitated by unregulated intermediaries who were here in Ontario, and they paid secret kickbacks to the insiders in South America,” says Gaytan.

“This case clearly shows that there is an opportunity for insiders to commit fraud, and then they find the proper parties elsewhere to commit these fraudulent activities.”

The 2018 Ontario Superior Court decision in the case is currently under appeal.

Gaytan says this type of corporate fraud is complex as it often involves an international network of individuals whose goal is to make it as challenging as possible to detect.

“Once the lawyers come into place, it is really hard to follow the path of these funds and to find out who was involved,” he says.

As such, one of the best ways to tackle this type of fraud case is to have local representation in each applicable jurisdiction, Gaytan says.

“In our case, we had lawyers in Ontario, but we worked together with lawyers in South America, which is where this pension fund is located. We also have lawyers in the United States, Europe and Central America. We know there was some activity in those jurisdictions. So, we basically have lawyers in every country where we know the funds went through,” he says.

While increasing employee awareness of the growing problem of fraud is one key to prevention, Gaytan says companies also need to implement more structure within the organization, boost compliance, ethics, and make legal improvements.

However, once a fraud has been identified, lawyers need to be brought in quickly, he says.

“One of the first things that a lawyer should do is consider putting Mareva injunctions in place, which is to try to freeze all the accounts and assets of the firm and/or individuals that are involved, and also try to consider Anton Piller orders, which basically give you the right to search the premises,” says Gaytan.

“It’s vital to act fast before any potential evidence can be destroyed, and to put all of these orders in place,” he says.

 


Date_Published
2019-10-17
Description

Christopher GaytanWhile judgments from criminal cases can be considered in related civil matters, they cannot be relied on by themselves to reach a decision, as a full civil trial may be necessary to assess the evidence, says Toronto commercial litigator Christopher Gaytan.

This is an excerpt from an article that appeared on AdvocateDaily.com.

Please click here to read the rest of the story.

Date_Published
2019-08-19
Description

Christopher GaytanToronto commercial litigator Christopher Gaytan brings a personal touch to the practice of law.

Although the legal profession maintains a stuffy reputation in both his native Mexico and his adopted home of Canada, Gaytan, an associate with Shibley Righton LLP’s Toronto office, tells AdvocateDaily.com that he likes to dispense with formality as much as possible when meeting clients.  

This is an excerpt from an article that appeared on AdvocateDaily.com.

Please click here to read the rest of the story.

Date_Published
2019-07-30
Experience
More About
BIO

Chris is a licensed lawyer in both Ontario and Mexico with experience providing a wide range of services to Latin American clients including commercial litigation, and multinational securities fraud recovery practices. Chris has been involved in commercial matters in the viatical settlements industry, land developments, securities brokerage, and cross border investments. 

Chris often works with international clients from Central and South America using his unique bilingual and multinational competency in the practice of law. These skills enable Chris to effectively bridge any cultural gaps and to overcome any language or cultural issues with his Latin American clients. Chris also has developed an expertise in translating legal documents and interpreting from Spanish to English and vice versa.

Chris obtained his LL.B. from the Universidad del Valle de Mexico in 2005 and was admitted to practice law in 2006. In 2012 he earned his LL.M. (Master of Laws) in International Business Law from Osgoode Hall Law School, and after being called to the bar in 2017 he became an associate at Shibley Righton.

In his free time, Chris enjoys playing and watching sports, he is an avid soccer player, he practiced martial arts for 10 years and has completed obstacle course races in Toronto. He also has a passion for travelling, having recently traveled to Dubai, Abu Dhabi, Tehran, Barcelona, Rome and Venice.

Contact Information

T: 416.214.5254
F: 416.214.5454
E: christopher.gaytan@shibleyrighton.com

vCard
Education

Universidad del Valle de Mexico, LL.B, 2005
Osgoode Hall Law School, LL.M. Internation Business Law, 2012

Featured